I stayed at Pop Century Dec. 2017. I'm staying off site for October's Pixelmania.
To sum up my opinion I do not believe that Disney resorts, especially Pop Century, are a good value these days as service and the physical plant is in decline and the prices and surliness of cast members is increasing. I have decided not to give my hotel room money to Disney and I'm staying off site. I will have my personal car so staying off site will work nicely for me. I'll lose access to the rides during Extra magic hours and I will only be able to book fast passes at 30 days out since I have an annual pass.
All this is fine with me. With the money I am saving by staying off site, every 3rd day is free when compared to Disney hotels. Between Housekeeping staff at Disney demanding immediate entry to your room for "inspections" (and pounding on the door until they gain entry) to crap up-charging for things like parking and dysfunctional bus service and housekeeping I am done for awhile at Disney Resorts if I am the one paying for the room.
Your mileage may vary... Be sure to book your room by MARCH 20th to avoid the new daily $13 parking fee, if you should decide to rent a car.
Pop used to be my go to resort. Disney ruined it with the industrial room remodel that is designed to decrease the amount of daily cleaning they are willing to do. Bus service has gotten worse and worse and the prices for the rooms are obscene IMHO. Putting up with all that crap is beyond my tolerance. I'm not up on the All star Resorts but they haven't been remodeled yet so they might be more comfortable.
You will have to decide for yourself if staying at a Disney resort is the right choice for you. All I'm saying is that it is not the right choice for me so please keep that in mind.
~Joanie