Looking to add a lens to my kit 18-55 on my D40

stephen

Member
I am not really going to do long range wildlife photos. Most will be in the Disney/vacation distances. Just looking for some opinions for a zoom or telephoto for my camera.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Budget?

The perfect match is the AF-S DX VR 55-200G.

But the better one would probably be the AF-S VR 70-300G. Both of these will AF with the D40.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
If you want the best of both worlds, the 'AF-S Zoom-Nikkor D 18 - 200 mm f/3.5 - 5.6G DX ED IF VR' (whew!) is a great lens for general walking around. (better resell value too should you choose to REALLY blow the budget and move up to FX).

To be honest, you can just about glue the 18-200 to the camera and forget about it for general family/vacation photos!
 
"mPower" said:
best of both worlds

Shhhhhhhhhhhh. That's the new Hannah Montanaâ„¢ edition of the lens to match with the new Black Gold D60.......
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Yeah, I saw that instead of the traditional 'Nikon Black' barrel they changed it to a very deep blue metallic, and also changed the red 'VR' badge to pink. The upside is that possession of the lens will afford a %2 discount on park admission.
 
"mPower" said:
If you want the best of both worlds, the 'AF-S Zoom-Nikkor D 18 - 200 mm f/3.5 - 5.6G DX ED IF VR' (whew!) is a great lens for general walking around. (better resell value too should you choose to REALLY blow the budget and move up to FX).

To be honest, you can just about glue the 18-200 to the camera and forget about it for general family/vacation photos!

I have the above 18-200 lens and I love it! Used it during my May WDW trip for everything.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
"meyernl" said:
I have the above 18-200 lens and I love it!  Used it during my May WDW trip for everything.

I have to agree here...I have the same lens, and use it most of the time in the day. I usually switch to my 50mm 1.8 at night - still trying to get better with that lens!
 
Last edited by a moderator:
As a walkabout and travel lens, it's hard to beat the Nikon 18-200 VR. Here's a link to a review I wrote soon after I got it.
http://www.themagicinpixels.com/forum/i ... 801.0.html

Most of the pictures I have posted here over the last year (unless noted) were taken with this lens. You should hear from Craig soon, too. He's another fan of this lens.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Is ~$680 a decent price for this lens?

Is the 18-55 VR worth it to replace the kit lens? or just stick with the 18-200?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
The 18-200 is probably one of the best DX lenses out there (other than the 17-55 2.8, 12-24/4), it more than outshines the other DX lenses, period.
 
"stephen" said:
Is ~$680 a decent price for this lens?

Is the 18-55 VR worth it to replace the kit lens? or just stick with the 18-200?

That is a good price. B&H has it a bit cheaper. Use the link at the top of this page. When I got mine they were in short supply and I ended up paying more than MSRP. My excuse is I had a WDW trip coming up fast. ;)

What I'd suggest is keep the 18-55 VR for if you ever sell your D40 as it will be easier to sell with a lens. Don't be nervous that the lens costs more than the camera, you'll be able to use it on newer cameras or sell it at a good price.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I love the 18-200. Picture quality is great, but more importantly is how CONVIENENT this lens is. Like mpower said, you can pretty much glue it on, especially at Disney.

Like Scott, I overpaid for mine too back in 2006, but I was also leaving for WDW in less than three weeks. That lens is a decision I have never regretted.

That lens started on my d80 and is now on the d300. So, you can definitely keep it if you get a new camera. remember lenses never get old or outdated. (dx vs. fx aside)

When buying Rogers's D300, one of my first thoughts was YAAAY, I get to keep my 18-200!!!
 
Count me among the 18-200 VR owners. I love the lens--it's actually the only one I have right now. I ended up paying $250 for mine, and it included a B+W UV filter and a Tiffen Polarizing filter. If money is an issue, I suggest looking for big packages on eBay (sold by individuals or authorized sellers, otherwise you'll get grey market) and reselling the items you don't want. I got really lucky when I bought mine, because some seller had just listed it with a D50 body for a really low price, and at the time I had a 10% off paypal coupon and Live.com was offering 25% cashback on eBay purchases. I later sold the D50, and ended up with a really sweet deal on the lens and a couple of nice filters.

If you buy new, I'd look for a better deal than $680. Last I saw on Amazon, it was around $660 with free shipping and no tax to most locations. Check Abes of Maine, too.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
OK, what is the real difference between f/2.8 and f/3.5. I know the definition, but not the real effective difference on a DSLR. I want to take picutres in dark rides sometimes :-)
 
Last edited by a moderator:
The difference is about a half to 2/3 of a stop.

Which would mean at the same ISO:

2.8 1/30 sec = 3.5 1/20 sec (about)


Considering that dark rides have an EV of about 5/6 at ISO 3200 (generally), the real difference is:

EV 6, ISO 3200: 1.4 1/30 sec = 2.8 1/8 sec = 3.5 1/5 sec approx.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
My D40 actually came with a 18-55 and a 55-200...

My 18 - 55 covers pretty much everything I do except in areas (like the theme parks) where I really want to zoom in on all the details. I carry both with me at all times. Having a 18 - 200 would have been soooo much more efficient.
 
I have a 18-55 and a 55 - 200...

I recommend you listen to those recommending the 18 -200!

I *wish* I had all in one instead of having to switch out my lenses.

I use both religiously, but the lens needed depends on where I'm at.

At MK I'd use the 18-55 for the castle and wider shots...but then would have to switch if I want to zoom in on details the 55 won't reach. It's a major annoyance you won't have to deal with if you buy the wider range lens.
 
"stephen" said:
Anybody know if the TAMRON 18-270 is worth looking at as an option to the Nikkor 18-200 VR?

Your Nikon will only work with specific lenses...

I am sure one of the guys will come by and tell you id the Tamron will work on your D40.
 
Back
Top